Thursday, April 15, 2010

Face book campaign - Intervention

We wanted people’s opinions on transgenders and if they would be comfortable with the presence of transgenders in their vicinity.
What better way than, on a social networking site! Facebook it is.
We asked various questions to people from different age groups ranging from 18-50.
We wanted to question ourselves on an everyday level.

We asked them questions like:

-Would you keep a transgender (hijra) as your domestic help?
-Are you friends with a transgender (hijra)? Would you mind being?
- Would you feel comfortable with your neighbor being transgender (hijra)?
- How would you react to your child’s teacher being transgender (hijra)?

We got a lot of positive responses from people:-

A lot of people said they would have no problems if a trans-gender was their neighbour.

People said they would be concerned about the teacher being a good one and whether their child was being taught properly.



The criteria applied to for the transgender would be the same as for the current house-help. They would not discriminate on the basis of gender, colour, religion and others.






Our take:
After going through a basket full of responses we thought we should take it one step forward.
We decided to invite Snehaprabha and Sunil to college and see how the Srishti community interacted with them. We wanted to see whether the community become one and the transgenders the “other”.

A love and hate relationship (Snehaprabha's story)

My  name is Rajshekhar. I was born and brought up in Bangalore. I have studied till the 8th grade. Its been 18 years since I left home. I was not comfortable staying with my family and surroundings since I was branded as a “Chaka”. So I moved out and found a Hijra community. One of the hijra’s took me to her house, so that I could pour out my feelings to her. I sensed that even this community would not be devoid of problems. Problems like sexual and oral abuse.

I was not quite stable at that time and had no place to stay. I became a part of the Hijra community 18 years ago. The Hijra’s I stayed with told me that I had to wear a “saree”. But I refused to wear one as I am the only son to my parents. My guru quoted that if “If you want to stay in this community, you have to wear a saree, pierce your ears and nose otherwise we will beat you up”. I completely disagreed to what she said.

Since my childhood I had decided that I wanted to be like a girl. Have a boy friend and I wanted a lot of freedom. Within the Hijra community I had two options either to beg or to become a sex- worker. I frankly did not want to do sex- work. Since I was young I was really confused and could not decide on what was right and what was wrong for me.

I then approached another guru and she accepted me as her daughter.

She took me to Bombay for “reeth”(formal adoption ceremony). After which she asked me if “I wanted to get castrated” and I refused. The thought of getting castrated by “Daima”(castration done without any operation/medicines) really frightened me and I ran away.

I started accompanying my guru to beg as there were hardly any Hijra’s seen then. My daily earnings would total up to Rs 2,000. Inspite of all this I felt that I was not doing the right thing so I ran away from my guru’s house and started sleeping on the streets. I was sexually harassed on the streets. So I went up to one of my friends and found out if I could get a house for myself. I was emotionally physically and mentally shattered. At that point I considered dieing a better option than living. She then suggested that I wear a “saree” during the day and wear “shirt and pant” at night. I tried this out for a few days but later people did recognize me and started pin-pointing at me.

Then one day I went to my “nani’s” house and she introduced me to one “hamam”. That was the first time I indulged in sex- work and did not find it satisfying. By then I had acquired a lot of knowledge on castration and considered the pros and cons. I decided to get castrated. My guru got me castrated.

I then stayed with my guru and lived my own life. During this time a small conflict occurred between me and my guru, (my guru wanted to stay with her boy friend and that was not acceptable to me) which made me want to commit suicide. But I was not successful.  I came back to my guru. Another “guru” then adopted me and made me stay with her.

I rethought about my life and how sex- work had become a profession and that my earnings had increased. So I decided to give my parents a share of the money I had earned. With this thought in my mind I went home. But they did not accept me I was beaten by them.

I returned to the Hijra community and my guru started a new “hamam” on my name. I interacted with a lot of boys there. I fell in love with one of them. He is a rickshaw driver. We had a great time together, sharing our thoughts, feelings and moving around in his rickshaw.

I later got to know that he was in love with another Hijra and wanted to get married to her. I attended his wedding. I realized that it was high time I told him about my feelings towards him. So that very night I told him that “I have loved you since a year.”

After a month the couple had a major fight. That is when my lover approached me and asked me “Do you still love me?  And how much?” and I told him that “I still love you and I will keep on loving you till I die. I can even commit suicide if you ask me to”. That day my lover and I had a long conversation and he asked me if I would leave sex- work for him, clear all my loans and if I would you like to stay with him after six months.  I agreed and I was excited to be with him.

I spoke to my guru regarding the conversation I had with my lover and she did not approve of it. So I left the Hijra community again and went and stayed with my boyfriend. The police found out that a hijra was staying with a male and I was been beaten by the police. I wanted to commit suicide so I hung myself from the fan.

My boyfriend consoled me and told me that I could stay with him forever. So I reassured myself.  We then went and told my boyfriend’s mother that I loved him.  She loaded me with a lot of questions like “Where are you from?” “How do you earn money?” So I truthfully told her everything. I told her that I stayed with my guru and I made a living through sex–work.

She accepted me as her son’s wife only within the house and not in public. During this phase, I was constantly tested by my mother in law. She did not believe the fact that I truly loved her son. She blackmailed me and made me do things to prove that I loved her son.

I was forcefully made to eat a full plate of rice on a full stomach. I would keep quiet and eat that extra plate of rice only because I truly loved him. Later in the night after my mother-in-law would fall asleep I would go away from the house and vomit out all the food.

My lover added to the misery. He would allow me to be with him only in the mornings and later at night I would have to go outside as he wanted to have sex with other hijra’s. I was extremely hurt. I hated going out of the room and patiently waiting till my lover had sex with the other hijra’s. I went through this torture only because I loved him immensely. He was beaten up by the other men in the society. I really disliked that and tried to stop the other men from hitting him.

Few days later my husband introduced me to one of his friends. I accepted him as my brother and tied a “rakhi” on his hand. We had a lot of conversations. We spoke about my husband. I told him that “I really loved him and I have done a lot for him till now. He is my life”. My husband then joined us in the conversation and asked me “If you love me so much, what will happen if I leave you and go?” I clearly told him that I will live the life that I lead earlier and live on the footpaths.

One fine day I sat back and thought of what I was doing with my life. I wanted to be around in the society, I wanted to earn a lot of money. That is when I went to my guru and told her of all that I had gone through. She helped me and got me a job in an organization.

That night I requested my husband to spend sometime with me and just listen to what I had to say. I wanted to tell him a lot of things. I told him how he had physically, emotionally and mentally abused me and how I still continued to be with him. I shared a lot of things that had been bothering me for a long time.

That night I just walked off from the house crying and went walking a long way and reached a park. I went in front of a tree and poured out all my feelings to it. When I went back home my husband was very suspicious about me going to the park. He asked me questions like “Who did you meet in the park?”, “What were you doing there for so long?”, “Do you have a boyfriend outside?” I clearly told him that I was speaking out to the tree in the park and I was all alone. I told him “My love for you is never ending, even if you don’t love me its fine but the one thing I expect from you is to put one garland of “Malligay” flowers on my dead body and just two drops of tears from your eyes, that’s all”.

The next day my husband approached his friend and told him about my love for him. That very night my husband came into the room and seeing me asleep sat next to the bed and held my feet and cried a lot. I was awake but pretended to be fast asleep. I did not do or say anything to see what he would say or do next.

It was my birthday the next day, so he wished me and surprised me with  movie tickets and a cake. He took me to my parents place to meet them. That was a memorable day for me and I met a lot of my friends and guru’s.

But my happiness did not last very long. That very night my husband’s first wife came to visit him and she wanted to have sex with him. I was extremely hurt when my husband agreed to do so.

My relationship with my husband is still not stable.

I eagerly wait to hear him truly say “I love you.”

 

Conversation with Snehaprabha

An appointment taken over the phone for an interview.
Snehaprabha a multi talented transgender working in an organization.
I had to just hit on the dart and she begun with her life story.
Long and descriptive was her life.
She went through a lot of ups and downs.
She took up a million challenges.
But never gave up!
Her life was quite harsh.
And struggled day and night.
But never gave up!
She is a firm person.
Believes in what she feels is right.
Her soul means a lot to her.
I was overwhelmed by what she said.
Thinking about her struggle made me share mine with her.
Expressing the pain I went through …
She totally got me!
She then understood that I had understood her too!
A two hour long conversation brought out a lot of feelings for each other.
Also looking at each others hardship..
Respect shot to the next level.
One statement that she said after the talk-
“What ever happens! Remember after your mother I am there for you”
Which will always be there in my heart.

Discovering a new world everyday (Revati's story)

Who am I ? I was born in Tamil Nadu and grew up with the name Annadurai. Ever since I can remember, I would help my mother with housework. I would sweep the entrance clean and cover it with “kolam”. At times, I tried on my sister's clothes and looked at myself in the mirror. I usually kept company with girls of my age and played with them. My brothers, friends, neighbors-would call me names such as “ali”, “onbathu”, “pombalasatti”. My teacher would pinch me in the thigh and ask why do you act like a girl? Behave like a proper male child. That was when I understood that I was behaving like a girl. I was happy being that way.

When I turned fifteen I began experiencing various feminine desires. I began to feel shy and self-conscious when men were around and felt a growing need to dress up and look good like women did.

I was male but had female instincts. Was I the only one who felt this way? Questions and doubts such as these came up all the time. I simply could not understand what was happening. Since I was physically male, I concealed my femininity, my desires, and found myself deeply shaken by my inability to hide these things for long. I could not concentrate on my studies. I failed my tenth standard examination and spent a year studying at home because of this.

Could I find somebody who felt the way I did? I began to seek people like myself. I once visited a hill-fort close to where I lived. I met people like myself there. I spoke to them of how I felt. I learnt from them of men who had become women.

I would visit this hill-fort often to meet my new friends and to express myself freely. I would sing and dance and spend time with them happily. My family began to restrict me. They began asking questions about where I was going and what I was doing. I was ordered to work as a cleaner on the lorry we owned. They would scold me while the people who worked for us were around and leave me feeling humiliated. I was asked to do all the difficult jobs that men normally did. I was unable to bear the physical and emotional torment from my family and so I ran away from home in search of places where hijra’s lived.

I found refuge with a hijra community some 50 kilometers from my native place. For the first time, I met people who had been operated and dressed like women. They would dance in the “Karagattam”. They also made periodic visits to Bombay and Delhi. I wanted to become a woman. I wanted to become like them. I asked if I too could wear a “saree”. They said I needed to grow my hair and get my nose and ears pierced before I could wear a “saree”. How long would it take for my hair to grow sufficiently long? I would weep silently because I had to dress like a man till this happened. There, I did whatever work they gave me. I also learnt to cook and to dance. Three months later I traveled to Delhi.

I got my ears and nose pierced, wore women's clothes and lived the life of a woman in Delhi. A hijra adopted me as her daughter and I would accompany her when she visited the shops for money. I didn't like doing this. I accompanied her because there was simply no other option.

My family found out that I was living in Delhi as a hijra and visiting shops for money. I returned home, when I received a word that my mother was seriously ill. I took off my hijra clothes at a railway station and went home dressed in male attire. I was apprehensive about my mother's health taking a turn for the worse if she saw me dressed in any other way.

At home, I found my mother was in good health. My older brother began beating me up with a cricket bat not caring about whether he hurt my head or my limbs. I screamed in unbearable pain. My mother urged him more. “Break his legs” she said. Prevent him from going with hijras again. I began to bleed from the head. I wept uncontrollably my body was covered entirely with bruises. I did not have the courage to stand up to them and express my femininity. I could not get over the fear that they would beat me some more and perhaps kill me.

They took me to the temple the next day and shaved my head. They had struck me several times, but their blows did not hurt as much as losing my hair did.

I was at home for about three months and then I ran away to Bombay. I joined a hijra community . It was here that I learnt of hijra life, of our culture and our traditions. I learnt of relationships within the community such as guru, “Chela” and “Nani”. The hijra community has seven houses. Each house has its own “Nayak”. To become somebody's “chela”, it is necessary to bring the seven “nayaks” together in a “jamaat” and place a “reethu” in their presence.

I learnt the rules of hijra life, that we never cut our hair, that we touch the feet of our elders when we begin and end each day that we must be careful about even our clothes coming in contact with elders. I learnt of how I was supposed to conduct myself in the presence of my guru and my “nani”.

I would visit shops. I also helped with the housework. Six months passed in this fashion. They sent me to Tamil Nadu for my “Nirvanam”. I completed my “nirvanam” and returned to Bombay suffering much hardship. Forty days after the ceremony, they performed the milk ritual. I went back to visiting shops.

I was very happy after my “nirvanam” because I felt that I had finally become a woman. I wanted to marry somebody and have my own family. But who marries hijras? It was also not possible to live alone - that was against the rules of our community. Such a life, even if I attempted it, would be one without any security.

I began to desire sex with men. The rule in our house was that we shouldn't see men or speak to them. This was a difficult situation. I couldn't hold myself back for very long. I broke with my house and joined another group which was involved in sex-work as “chela” to another hijra in that house. Joining another house while you are still a “chela” can lead to fights and violence. The only way to avoid such a situation is to become a “chela” to another hijra in that house.

I began to seek sex-work. I was able to have sexual relations with men but it was not very satisfying. With customers, you have to do what they want if you want to get paid. I was forced to have sex even when I didn't feel like it because l needed the money. Even though I made good money and handed it all promptly to my guru, I was never given good clothes. And sometimes, local “goondas” would force me into sex without paying for it.

Once a “goonda” forced himself on me in a way that I found inappropriate. It hurt me in many ways than one. My guru did not lift a finger to help me. Sex-work was possible in our locality only if you did what the “goondas” asked you to do. I barely survived that experience. I didn't want to stay there any more. I wondered where I could go. Society looks down at us. We don't get jobs. We were treated badly. To add to all this the policemen and “goondas” add to the misery. After thinking about all these things I decided to return home to my native place.

I went home as a woman for the first time. My brother tried to beat me again. I yelled that I was a woman. That I would go to the police if he laid a hand on me. I displayed the result of my “nirvanam” to them. They told me that I must wear men’s clothes. I declared that I couldn’t do all that any longer. My father who understood my feelings said let him be as he wishes. I was however not allowed to step out of the house. I could not take part in public functions on occasions. My relatives and acquaintances visited me as they would visit somebody who was ill. They began to look at me in a strange way. Everyone began gossiping about me.

I did not wish to continue living there. I left home and joined a hijra group in Bangalore. I became a sex-worker in my new guru’s “hammam”. I realized that I would get respect only if I had money. I worked in Bangalore for five years and saved the hard earned money.

I gave my guru and my family money occasionally. I got treated with respect only when I did this, both by my family and within my hijra group. I would go home now and then and give my father the money I had saved. I told him that I had begun dancing, and that my earnings came from this activity. I did not tell them anything about my sex-work. These visits home would sometimes last as long as ten days. They let me move about freely and did not try to restrict me in any way.

When I traveled by bus, women would not sit next to me if they guessed that I was a hijra. People in the bus would tease me mercilessly. Some men would try to grope me too. My life went this way every day, fearing society, “goondas” and the police. I would venture out of the “hammam” into the streets of Bangalore for sex-work. I pretended to be a woman while seeking customers. Nobody would have come to me if I had let the fact that I was hijra. People in cars would pick me up. On several occasions we were chased by policemen who were following me in “mufti”. They would slap me around and chase me away before getting money from my customers. The fear would make me give them money.

I’ve been dragged into their vans while walking the streets. At the station they would beat me and kick me and humiliate me with questions like “How do you have a woman’s body? show us.” They would keep me there for two days and torture me no case was ever registered. They would then drag me to court. At the entrance, they would make me give them money, say two hundred rupees, and then tell me to go away. I would live in constant fear of the police while seeking sex work. Whether I went out for sex work or not, I had to give my guru a hundred rupees every day. Only then could I stay at their house.

Once while I was looking for customers, some policemen stopped me and forced me trap people for them. They were waiting to collare the customers who approached me to discuss my rate. A few people who stopped to ask for directions also got arrested. They caught some ten people this way and then beat me up and said “Get lost, if we see you here again, we’ll put you in jail for six months.”

Once, at a police station I was beaten up, tortured, and forced to eat off the floor on a cold winter day. I was made to sweep the entire station clean. Whenever something like this happened I would ask myself “Why am I suffering like this? And whether the cause for the trouble was because I did sex-work. If working elsewhere was possible, I could live like other women. I would weep bitterly because I knew that these options didn't exist.

Once, while walking by some street two men stopped me and tried to take me along with them. When I refused, one of them pulled out a knife and tried to stick it in my face. I warded off the jab with my hand-bag and the knife landed on my hand. I yelled ‘police, police’ loudly and they ran away. I have to live with my heart in my mouth from the moment I step out of the house till the moment I returned home.

I decided not to do sex-work. How long could anybody deal with all these things? Police, “goondas”, everybody. I returned to my native place. At home, I helped my parents around the house. My strongest desire was to live the life of a woman, to marry the man I liked, to find a job I could do. In trying to become a woman I had ended up living the life of a hijra among other hijras. I needed money to live with respect in society, to wear nice clothes, and to meet my daily needs. Having no real option, I was forced to take up sex-work to make enough money for my needs. I had to buy the love of those around me with money. I had to deal with policemen and their torture. This society does not look at me favorably. The legal system refuses to provide facilities or assistance. My family treats me well only if l give them money. I was sick of life, thinking of all this and wanted to do something to end my life.

Seeing me in this state, my mother asked “Why are you like this, why are you in this state of collapse?” “This is why we beat you, because we didn't want you to become a hijra.” “What is the use of being depressed now?” “ Are you now unhappy in this woman's guise? I said it's not what you think. “I want to live the life of a woman.” I am being what I want to be. I am unhappy because I can't find a decent job or get married. My mother said “Marriage for you? With a man? Can you bear a child for him? Your being a hijra is enough humiliation for us. If you get married the little dignity we have will also go.”

Even if my dreams had to be bundled up into a gunny bag and forgotten, I felt that others like me should not end up the way I did. What could I do to ensure that? And how? I didn't know. At this point I found a job in an organization in Bangalore.


An organization that fights for the rights of sexual minorities. I am now able to work for my people because of this organization. I am not at fault for the way I am today. I think it is society and its laws that look at me in a prejudiced manner. I shared my experiences - of hijra life and police atrocities – with various organisations and spoke of them at public functions. I am thus bringing about some awareness about what it is to be hijra .

I got married, but it broke up in about a year. I wanted to live like a woman but was not allowed the rights of a woman by my husband. He wanted his freedom. We parted ways because of these things. It may be more correct to say that I was divorced by my husband rather than to say that I divorced him.

I am now writing an autobiography. I will soon publish it in English, Kannada and Tamil. After a long struggle, I have taken a passport as a woman. I take pleasure in describing myself as a woman. I desire to see our society and its legal system accept us as women, and accept the entire hijra community.

Dialouge with Revati

Revati is a transgender .
She is the first transgender we ever interacted with.
She is currently working as the department head in a human rights organization.
I went to meet her with an open mind. My first question to her was
HOW HAS LIFE BEEN FOR YOU TILL NOW?

She then frankly asked me if I was asking her to narrate her life story to me. And if that is the case, then she is really not enthusiastic about it, as she had repeated it over a million times by then.

So I initiated the conversation by asking her how life was for her as a child.
She got comfortable and started opening up and told me about her days in school. How she enjoyed playing and being with girls rather than boys. As she grew how she was discriminated by her peers and teachers. After a point she was discriminated where ever she went. May it be at home, school, neighbors and others. While listening to her I could really understand the hardships, torture and trauma that she had gone through. Constantly fighting against all odds had transformed her. She became mature and was aware of how she was. She is independent, courageous and determined. It really was amazing to see how she had grown. She even adopted a daughter. Her world now revolves only around her work and her daughter. I really connected to this as I share a similar relationship with my mother.

Wednesday, April 14, 2010

The journey of Gender

Gender is fluid. Gender is performance. Gender is historical an experience. Gender is social, political, cultural, economic roles. Gender is complex composition of many things around us; of carrying out a certain body in a certain fixed, rigid, unwritten norms convenient to the hetero-patriarchal system. It is a transgression; a breaking of boundaries to experience freedom of expression. It is a journey of life; a journey from body to mind, body type to a culture of living, a personal journey – leading to a political journey; that which is an assumed threat to the historical existence of patriarchy, reproductive based living and “male/man power”. 

In this journey of gender, different people express their gender differently or even break the norms or rigidity to their needs. The norms of gender based on social morality are rigid and claustrophobic. It forces people into a homogenic life of hegemony. While the women’s movement did break gender norms for the rights for women in terms of mobility, right to body, consent, social institutions etc. At the same time one can also recognize that hetero-patriarchy at its convenience has loosened the norms of gender around the economic sphere but without separating the sex-gender associated roles and traits.

On the contrary life offers diversity and multiplicity in all spheres and gender is one of the many expression modes and a major part of a person’s individuality. The hetero-patriarchal system makes this journey of gender so rigid that many times, that this could be one of the reasons for the shift in gender. The concept of “Trans” is a journey from the assigned gender or sex to a comfortable, aspired gender or sex. It is the individual’s choice to complete the journey or not. Many times the individual might not want to stay in a particular phase which is neither of the extremes of the “two points”. 

The problem is – this journey is visualized or understood as a horizontal single layered straight journey from point one to point two being male to female or visa versa – this is the binary that is fixed by the society. If this perspective can be changed to understand and visualize a circle of gender expressions, which could be according to the individual’s understanding or choice the fluidity can be retained. Retaining of fluidity makes space for freedom of expression and also growth of the individual in multi-spheres more comfortably than that of restricted fixtures of positions becoming life’s inevitability.

The present system of gender and sex is not only mixed up but also very much based on the hetero-patriarchal convenient rigid boxes – the box that jails an individual for a life-time of feeling incomplete. There are many efforts from centuries to break the boxes. Even when you break the boxes you remain outsider. Even the trans journey ends up reinforcing the hetero-patriarchal convenient boxes of gender, for the want of validation with respect and dignity. Unfortunately this is such a trap that neither being in box faithfully nor shifting from one to another or remaining in a self defined or undefined sphere of gender helps or is inclusive. There is a continuous experience of discrimination, lack of recognition, no dignity of self’s identity along with individual’s and human rights violations.  Sex is also not binary. It is multiple. Gender is also not binary it is multiple. The experience is rich and the journey in both sex and gender is the individual’s right.

Most of the social movements for rights have mostly worked within this hetero-patriarchal convenient reproductive paradigm of understanding sex and gender. There is no distinction between sex and gender to understand the body and its rights and the choice of the individual to exercise the right. The asserting of right of a person’s body and the associated self’s dignity as a choice will open up larger debates around many issues including sex as work or as an institution of exploitation. It is about a personal choice over the body and the life around the gender expressions. Yes at one level one cannot totally separate the historical link between sex and gender. The complex angle contributing to these issues of sex and gender is sexuality. That too is not binary. That too has multiple expressions. It furthers the rich layers of the ‘self’. 

Many people have experienced this discrimination, humiliation, no rights, unwanted sympathy, and painful exclusions, of being out of the common, etc. This process becomes doubly difficult for the female born population who are marginalized based on sex and gender. They do not even have the back up of cultural or traditional or evidently visible divine interventions (like that of godly traditions that support trans people).

Rethinking Sex and Gender Binary

Its sad how a transgender’s entire life revolves around his/her gender with no fault of their own. And the same rule doesn’t apply  to us. Our lives are not governed by our gender alone.

We forget that as human beings we are born gender neutral. It is society that pushes us into being this or that. And as human beings we like order, we like to compartmentalize things. Chaos is generally not acceptable. So categorizing oneself as male or female is absolutely necessary. One cannot be both.We all have multiple identities. We are born multiple sexes. But along the way we acquire a need to define ourselves. Until a certain age, a child is never even aware about his/her gender. But gradually he or she is consciously made aware of his/her gender and constantly told to do things based on his/her gender.

The present social and citizenship identification system is based on a confused understanding of biological sex and stereo typed associated gender. Many times the ID cards state options like “Gender” – Male and Female or “Sex” – Man and Woman. This is not just a technical problem in understanding or a grammatical mistake. The problem arises because we consider gender to be binary. We forget that the transgender exist. This is an entire system of exclusion and an old system of identifying people in the reproductive paradigm.  A male person, whose body has penis, testicles, can also produce, has to be masculine. Similarly a female person, whose body has vagina, uterus, breasts, can also produce, has to be feminine. This whole range of understanding is a familial understanding and not a social understanding.  The traits ascribed to both femininity and masculinity is mostly based on the conditions that support and promote patriarchal family system. This gets extended to the government administrative system, judiciary systems, constitution and social systems. People who voluntarily choose their gender or people who by biological difference do not fit into this description of familial understanding of “gender or sex” are excluded in all aspects – fundamental rights, human rights, citizenship rights, entitlements, social, political, cultural acceptance and acceptance by the family.  A whole range of people who identify “trans”, “intersex” or the ones who do not identify with either not only get excluded and denied of rights but also face severe discrimination, ridicule, get punished, under go forcible corrective measures, thrown out of support systems, and non-acceptance driving the person to the extent of suicide.

Our government systems, social, economic, labour, political, cultural, civil systems do not even accept slight difference in the identification process. For example a male born person who looks differently, probably like a woman but produces certificates as male is not only questioned about their identity but also many times threatened to check for the correct sex/ gender which is confused in their mind. They also suggest corrective measures to fit in to “correct boxes”. If this is resented they loose the opportunity. Even for people who might want to express their gender differently but would not mind accepting the sex binary that is assumed in our society there is no space, because sex and gender blurs in all systems and the “appearance” matters. Though this constitution recognizes individual rights with dignity it is because of this appearance, that people get denied of their rights.

The present system which some what operates based on binary sex but insists on associated traits of gender does not offer any options to people who are out side the defined boxes of gender. To add to this people who break this defined boxes in different phases are accepted or not accepted based on the extent of loyalty that is shown to the defined boxes.

Transgenders are very often called nature’s mistake or nature’s injustice. How can we as one of the creations of nature, call another creation a mistake. Who gives us that authority? And what entitles us to be a justified creation?

We are ready to accept diversity and multiplicity in all spheres. Why not gender?

The present system which some what operates based on binary sex but insists on associated traits of gender does not offer any options to people who are out side the defined boxes of gender. To add to this people who break these defined boxes in different phases are accepted or not accepted based on the extent of loyalty that is shown to the defined boxes. In this context if one proposes the idea of an entirely biological sex based identification system, it still does not recognize in a rights based manner the minuscule population of intersex people. There are corrective measures everywhere. Again based on the reproductive paradigm the body that is made of a different composition which includes both male and female is considered defective. So, clearly the attitude is mainly to correct people and put them either under male or female, or, man or women. The attitude clearly does not give any choice to people or a right on their own body. This also extends to people having no choice to decide their identity in social, political, cultural, economic, and civil roles. Of course the modern technology offers these corrective surgeries, therapies, treatments but one does not recognize the fact that not all people can afford the surgery, not all people choose surgery, some people might just want the change in appearance, some people may just want change in gender and some people cannot just opt for surgery due to family pressure, societal pressure, or there will not be that space to openly opt for the surgery.

On the other hand if we look at the present system, we feel that our constitution and government are lazy to wake up to the fact that we will have to change an entire system of operations, plus attitudes and make spaces that have been historically occupied conveniently being blind to the existence of people’s different expressions of sex and gender. The change would mean a systemic change, which recognizes the historical oppressions based on gender, Trans and Intersex people, women, people who identify as women or men, people who are different in their bodies and have a choice in their sex and gender. It would mean change in attitudes, language, judiciary process and constitution. This would mean bringing difference between sex and gender resulting in change of standards in social, political, economic, cultural, labour, civil, and the list is in exhaustive.  It really means “CHANGE” - colossal work.  

While these systems are blind to change conveniently, the offer that is now made in an attempt to recognize is based on sympathy. It is not based on rights of the marginalized. For example – if there are two people sitting comfortably on a bench and for a long time feel that the ones not like them should sit, they will suddenly develop sympathy for the “others”, who are standing and are not like them. They will then say “we will give to people like you a little space on this bench and people like you should adjust within this space”.  This could also be a patch up effort to shut the noises which are demanding recognition. The attitude is to just adjust within the binary system or creating another space called “Other, Eunuch or TG” to make it more exclusive. So in this process we still maintain the binary system intact. Even this “Other” space is boxed and restricted. While equality that is substantive, that which is inclusive and makes space for everyone is out of the window. There is no effort to put more benches to provide the rightful space.

The binary sex-gender system adopted by the government administrative and judiciary process and of rights in the constitution could be due to lack of consultation of all public. Or, the general public have historical convenience to not to recognize the people who are marginalized based on sex and gender. But the gender diversity is historical and evident. Unfortunately through this sex-gender binary the space for gender diversity expressions is closed. In this process communities that are marginalized based on sex and gender stand out as a newly evolving concept and further get discriminated along with historical discrimination and rights violations.